Peak vs baseload forward curves: understanding spreads and risk
What peak and baseload products represent
While both are related to how we use the forward curve in trading, peak and baseload products differ in what insights we use them for and when.
Baseload = continuous delivery
Baseload products represent continuously, uninterrupted energy, 24 hours per day, seven days per week. We use this to measure the bare minimum requirements of the grid.
Peak = daytime/high-demand hours
Peak products refer to energy delivered during peak periods, which tend to be to industrial daytime loads and mornings and evenings for the residential market during weekdays.
Contract definitions in exchanges
Exchanges provide power products that are measured via contracts segmented into months, quarters, or seasons. Some of the exchanges that traders may come into contact with might include EPEX SPOT or the European Energy Exchange (EEX). The calculation we use is based on how much power is delivered within a certain timeframe, so for example a 1MW baseload contract would deliver 1MW per hour for the duration a contract.
Why peak carries a risk premium
Higher costs and risk are usually associated with peak power curves and they also tend to experience a more restricted supply-demand balance.
Demand uncertainty
Because energy demand increases or decreases with weather behaviour, it can make forecasting difficult. This leaves disparities between the amount of energy produced and the amount of energy required.
Scarcity risk during peak hours
Scarcity risk premiums may be built into forward prices to help mitigate the risk of unexpected price increases, thereby addressing supply failures. This is particularly poignant in the case of a PPA when supply promises cannot be achieved, as a risk premium can help to alleviate the penalties.
Limited flexibility supply
While peaking plants can fire up quickly, they struggle to meet continuous demand. This makes them less flexible than baseload plants, which can be used to balance out the volatility of the influx of renewable sources entering the grid.
Renewables and peak price behaviour
Energy traders use baseload and peak curves to give a picture of the power landscape in comparison to peak periods of generation and consumption.
Solar flattening midday peaks
As solar energy makes its presence known in the energy market, its key impact on the forward curve is by flattening midday peaks. During daytime hours, when residential demand is over, particularly in the winter months, solar overproduces energy, causing midday prices to collapse. This means that evening prices rise: the exact time when solar production drops.
Evening ramp increasing volatility
This increase in demand during the evening is what’s known as the evening ramp. This can cause certain regions with high solar penetration, such as the US, to require generators to keep the lights on during the evening ramp period.
Wind variability impacts
Wind energy is one of the more unpredictable energy sources in the renewable portfolio, which makes it more difficult for peak generation to be a profitable option. When wind energy increases, prices can crash during peak hours because wind has very low marginal costs.
Peak-base spread dynamics
We refer to the price difference between baseload-period-delivered energy and peak-period-delivered energy. This information, such as how tight or volatile a system is, can be used to assess the market's state at that time.
Spread widening during stress
The spread between peak and baseload widens when the market is more volatile, so as the risk increases, traders tend to exit the market, putting further stress on the market.
Impact of system tightness
The grid then tightens as a result of resource adequacy. This volatility can be influenced by the increase of renewable energy in the grid, which requires peaking capacity to level the grid during off-peak periods. The baseload and peak base can then widen or tighten without warning.
Regional differences
In the USA, peak-base spreads often occur during the summer when air conditioning requirements increase due to the heat. In Europe, the spreads are smaller, but wider, due to seasonal differences throughout the year.
Trading and hedging implications
For traders to effectively maximise revenue and avoid risk, it's key that they understand and utilise data from baseload and peak power curves. It’s important to keep in mind that baseload curves tend to be less volatile than peak curves.
Spread trading strategies that traders might utilise include exploiting the spread between peak and baseload pricing, potentially using the day-ahead market to identify patterns in expectations of pricing versus the reality of pricing. They might also look at opportunities to exploit regional pricing differences and trade across these different areas.
Hedging peak exposure is another strategy useful to traders, though hedging peak load is much more complex than hedging baseload. Finally, traders may execute portfolio balancing strategies to identify opportunities: using a mix of off-peak and peak contracts alongside baseload contracts could offer a more cost-effective approach to load curves. While trading in the renewables sphere can offer profitable opportunities, its volatility requires sophisticated trading strategies, including integrating PPAs, storage and batteries, or taking spot market positions.



.jpeg)




