Liquidity in power forward markets: execution and risk
Market fundamentals
Selling energy at volume is what’s at the heart of good liquidity in the market. Liquidity allows these large sales and purchases to take place without price shifts disturbing the market too much. Factors that affect liquidity connect up risk management by traders with the actual supply realities at that time:
1. Fuel prices plus generation costs
Hedging strategies can be informed by the behaviour of energy prices for coal, gas and carbon allowances, as they are the driving force behind electricity prices. When the cost of capital changes, so does liquidity.
2. Renewable energy intermittency
Liquidity in long-term forward curves can be reduced due to the unpredictability of solar and wind power as they become more prevalent in the market.
3. Extreme weather conditions
When weather conditions are more extreme, for example, in the case of winter, more heating is required, increasing demand for energy, creating volatility in the market.
4. Regulatory frameworks
Market depth can be reduced by regulatory changes or uncertainty, particularly around energy prices. This can discourage market participants from entering, thereby affecting liquidity.
5. Market structure and concentration
When many market participants cause a lot of liquidity in the market, when a market is monopolised (only includes a few large players), liquidity can be much lower.
6. Cross-border integration
Different borders have different regulations and policies, so when forward markets cross borders, they can become fragmented, reducing liquidity.
7.Liquidity and positioning
Liquidity varies with market conditions; for example, net-term monthly markets tend to have the highest liquidity, but as they mature over a longer period, liquidity drops off.
Market behaviours
Forward markets often exhibit low or thin liquidity, especially for longer-term contracts. This also depends on the behaviour of market participants - if the market has many participants, liquidity is higher; with fewer participants, it becomes thinner.
How the phenomenon appears in curves
The forward curve is directly affected by liquidity levels and by its reliability as a source. One of the key ways that liquidity changes the shape of the forward curve is through what’s known as the liquidity cliff. As a contract approaches maturity, liquidity thins relative to the start of the contract, when liquidity is typically high. When noisy curves occur, it’s because the forward curve has become disjointed due to a lack of information for traders to trade on and so estimation of data results in a noisy curve. While it's easy to think of the forward curve as a single, smooth line, in reality it's a collection of weeks. Liquidity shifts between these weeks, often focusing on short-term rather than long-term contracts.
Typical patterns observed
Quiet periods during seasonality: when prime trading periods are closed, we see seasonal quiet periods that lead to wider spreads and greater risk.
Long-term products with high spreads: as we move further along the curve to maturer contracts, bid-ask spreads get larger.
Near-term liquidity increases: we find liquidity is highest near the delivery date and decreases as the contract moves forward.
Liquid products contract with volatile strips: it can be hard to hedge in certain markets, for example, during ‘strips’ of months that show lower liquidity
Trading implications
How traders act on signals
Traders can utilise a number of different data sources in order to pick up on liquidity signals in forward markets. We take a look at the four main categories that traders will look at: technical, structural, fundamental and renewable.
Technical: liquidity pools are usually found near trend lines or particularly high or low periods in the market. Traders will try to predict when participants move prices before a reversal.
Structural: traders compare day-ahead spreads with real-time prices and identify profit potential if future pricing is lower than the current energy rate, buying cheaper energy in advance.
Fundamental: weather forecasts, carbon allowance prices and a change in coal and gas prices are all fundamental indicators that traders will keep an eye on to inform trading decisions.
Renewable - when renewable output increases, the intraday market may switch to immediate selling in order to offload excess energy.
Examples of strategies
Location spread trading: identifying and trading against price differentials in different regions.
Forward-to-spot arbitrage: locking in prices with a forward contract but buying during lower periods in the market means that traders can profit from the spread.
Spread trading: paying attention to the curve to identify opportunities between different delivery periods, particularly if the spread seems to be misplaced.
Liquidity sweep: unexpected spikes in the market can be predicted by traders, allowing them to set orders near resistance levels to profit before a trend reversal occurs.
Risk considerations
As with all energy trading, risk is always at the forefront of every trading decision. While long-term contracts might seem like a safe bet, they come with their own risk as liquidity thins out towards the end of the contract. Traders might employ over-the-counter brokers (OTC) to help out with larger, riskier contracts. There is also a real danger of mispricing and model risk because the data sources used to inform standard models aren’t sufficiently accurate to support informed trading decisions, which is often why mispricing occurs in the first place.



.jpeg)

