Forward curve dislocations: identifying mispricing opportunities
.webp)
Market fundamentals
When the price of future delivery contracts differs significantly from the spot price or the current market value, it can be an opportunity for traders to exploit incorrect forward curves for profit. These deviations often occur even when the usual indicators are there, for example, usual demand or enough available storage.
Liquidity and positioning
When liquidity is low, this can cause dislocation from the forward curve. This is particularly poignant during month-end or quarter-end periods. When regulatory pressures, such as carbon pricing, are applied, the market may not be able to generate enough energy because operating costs could be too high, which can also reduce liquidity.
Market behaviour
Forward curve dislocations often arise from panic or speculative market insight, which can cause mispricing. Usually, the market reads the spot prices as higher than the future prices, which prioritises storage options. During periods of low inventory, spot prices are above future prices, encouraging immediate sales. Behaviour is often driven by speculators who chase profit rather than examining actual supply and demand at that time.
How the phenomenon appears in curves
Dislocations can be identified as abnormal shapes in the forward curves' usual shape. False curves happen when, despite low inventory, the front-month prices still fall. We might see price spreads on a regional basis, for example, in transport fuel costs, which might show in the forward curve. This might be because of supply or demand changes, or because certain energy infrastructure has failed.
Typical patterns observed
Changes in what’s known as the basis, or the spot minus the forward, can often exhibit volatility, which can become dislocated from factors such as interest rates or the cost of storage. This is an indicator of mispricing.
Trading implications
Trading in an environment of forward curve dislocations is a high-risk but high-reward one. Traders can buy underpriced inventory and sell off more expensive alternatives while benefiting from a distorted spread.
How traders act on signals
Traders can benefit from shortage signals, which is when suppliers hold a lot of inventory and can indicate a large bubble will occur over the next few weeks. This allows for inventory to be sold as high-priced near-term contracts and low-priced deferred contracts.
Examples of strategies
Seasonal demand can affect the forward curve: winter heating pushes up demand, but if the forward curve doesn’t move, the expected deviation presents an opportunity for traders to exploit the divergence. There are a number of other signs that traders can look out for in order to identify mis-pricing opportunities:
1. Curve reverse - Traders can exploit calendar spreads, which look at mispriced short-term contracts that are expected to return to more stable long-term fundamentals.
2. Non-fundamental flows - Traders can follow Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Commitment of Traders (COT) reports to attempt to identify unfounded speculative positions.
3. Arbitrage Parity Violations - Markets that are experiencing high levels of volatility might be closely monitored by traders to try and identify violations of no-arbitrage relationships.
4. Convergence trading - Traders can benefit from convergence trading, which involves bets on the forward price reverting to its expected value.
Risk considerations
While trading during forward curve dislocations can offer lucrative opportunities for careful traders, it can also entail significant risk. Over the duration of the dislocation, the divergence can worsen, which requires capital to plug the gap. Liquidity can also be affected, potentially hindering exit routes if the trade does not go as expected. When market sentiment changes without warning, it can cause forced selling with potential losses if the position is too crowded.
Execution risk
Execution risk can also be a problem, as it occurs when an entire arbitrage portfolio cannot be executed at expected prices. In the case of partial fills, only one side of the trade might execute, leaving a trader with an exposed, unhedged position. Many traders may also jump on the same bandwagon after identifying an opportunity, leading to crowded trades and potentially higher transaction costs.
Mispricing and model risk
Models that don’t reflect actual market conditions are what’s known as model risk. This can be a problem when trading because we don’t know the full, accurate picture. Models are based on historical data, but when the market is acting as expected, we are trading in an environment that is the opposite. We can assume, and hope, that the market will return to less volatile, stable conditions in the short-term, but the fair value calculation may have changed the forward curve entirely, preventing it from returning to the expected shape. Because all opportunities are based on misevaluations and inaccurate data, the data we are relying on to identify opportunities may not be accurate enough to identify a so-called opportunity. It’s also worth bearing in mind that the volatility and irrationality of dislocated markets can continue longer than usual markets. This can lead to more significant losses in convergence trades.



.jpeg)




.webp)